The Heisman race has gotten muddier, not clearer, the last couple weeks. However, there are now only six players left who can actually still win the Heisman. Remember that the following list is NOT the predicted order of the vote, but a ranking of the players with the best chance at actually winning. Here they are:
1. Darren McFadden, Arkansas–McFadden had another strong game this past Saturday, rushing for 173 yards against Alabama. However, the Razorbacks lost for the second week in a row and THE CENTRAL QUESTION of the McFadden candidacy is now: How many losses will Heisman voters tolerate? The Hogs still must play Auburn, South Carolina, Tennessee and LSU. If it turns out that the Hogs win at least three of those four, then there shouldn’t be a problem. But if Arkansas drops two of the four, then we are talking about a Heisman candidate from a four-loss team.
The last team with at least four losses at the time of the Heisman vote to still produce a winner was Notre Dame in 1956 (Paul Hornung).
McFadden and Hornung might have a bit in common soon
On a positive note, McFadden leads the nation in rushing at 173 yards per game. He has 519 yards and 4 rushing touchdowns this season and is on pace to have 2,076 yards by the time of the Heisman vote. If McFadden hits the 2,000-yard mark, it may not matter if Arkanasas loses four times.
2. John David Booty, USC–Booty had a big game against Washington State, throwing for 279 yards and four touchdowns. On the season, he has 629 passing yards, 9 TD passes and 2 interceptions. He is on pace to throw for 36 touchdowns by the time of the Heisman vote, but he needs to pick up the pace in the yardage department if he is to have Heisman-worthy stats across the board.
If Booty can put together three or four games in row of this caliber–and USC stays undefeated–then he might jump back into the front runner position.
3. Patrick White, West Virginia–White was a fantastic 18 of 20 for 181 yards (and two scores) against East Carolina and he also added 42 yards and two scores on the ground. On the season, he has 617 passing yards and 286 rushing yards and a combined 12 TDs running and throwing.
At this point, it appears White is the main threat to Booty as the top quarterback Heisman candidate.
4. Jamaal Charles, Texas–Charles had just 72 yards on 14 carries in a blowout of Rice, but he did score three times. On the year, he has 471 rushing yards and six touchdowns.
Charles will make or break his Heisman campaign against Oklahoma. A big game will vault him into contention, but a bad game will cause him to drop out altogether.
5. Steve Slaton, West Virginia–Slaton ran for 110 yards and a score against East Carolina. On the year, he has 502 yards and nine touchdowns.
Slaton probably needs to pick up the pace a little to separate himself from the pack. It helps that Noel Devine cooled off last week.
6. Colt Brennan, Hawaii–Brennan is barely hanging on in the rankings right now. He did not play last week and that is a big blow to his Heisman hopes as he needs to surpass what he did last season statistically to really have a shot. Missing out on a turkey shoot against Charleston Southern doesn’t help.
Hanging by a thread
Dropped Out: Briahn Brohm; DeSean Jackson
Brohm is putting up monster numbers, but you can’t win a Heisman playing for Louisville when you lose to a 35-point underdog. Jackson is an exciting player, but he will not accumulate enough stats to merit serious consideration.
IF THE VOTE WERE HELD TODAY
1. Darren McFadden
2. Tim Tebow
3. John David Booty
4. Pat White
5. Andre Woodson
6. Michael Hart
7. Sam Bradford
8. Steve Slaton
9. Colt Brennan
10. Ray Rice






