We are coming to the end of the regular season and, as usual, there is the requisite complaints about the BCS and, naturally, the usual huffing and puffing over a possible playoff and how great it would be.
First off, let’s get one thing clear: College football is imperfect. It is wonderfully imperfect. There’s nothing like it in sports and I don’t like the idea of changing it. For those who want playoffs, I submit to you Sundays and all that comes with it. (A friend of mine asked me if I was going to watch the Cowboys and Packers play the other night. “Not planning on it,” I said. “Why not? It’s a huge game!” said the friend. “It is? So you are saying that the loser won’t be able to win the Super Bowl?” “Well, no. But, it’s a huge game!” “No thanks.” I still have no idea who won.)
So, I will continue to preach against the creeping NFL-ization of the game.
But that doesn’t mean there aren’t some reforms that can’t take place. I have a few ideas that I think would help the current BCS situation.
1. Schedule Reform
People are always griping about who plays who. You have elite teams playing creampuffs and missing out on winning titles and creampuffs going undefeated and getting no respect. The only way to get rid of it all is to have schedule reform. That means no non-I-A opponents if you want to contend for a title. Everyone’s non-conference schedule should be determined the same way the NFL does it: By seeding teams based on the previous season and giving the weaker teams easier schedules. The top teams would be forced to play a tough OOC schedule and, at the end, there would be no room to complain.
That also means no seven and eight home game schedules. Any team that plays more than six home games should be ineligible for the BCS. Yes, I know, it’s VERY important for teams to turn a buck. Well, if you are an A.D. and making extra money is more important to you than winning a title, then by all means schedule eight home games and don’t win one. Have fun.
Once we get to the point where teams are playing comparable schedules with no distortions due to too many home games or not enough road games, then the bitching about that element of the BCS will decline.
2. Conference Reform
This one is simple. There should be the same amount of teams in every conference. No more of the Big East having eight teams and the SEC having 12 and the Pac-10 having 10. This creates distortions in the schedules which in turn distorts the BCS rankings.
Every major conference should have 10 teams and there should be 12 conferences (mathematically easy with the coming edition of Western Kentucky to 1-A). Then, every conference should play a round-robin schedule, meaning that each team faces every other team within the conference. There would be no conference championship games, so the winner of the conference would be the true winner. Every team would have nine conference games and three non-conference games, which would be determined by the aforementioned scheduling system and a rotating series between conferences (Big Ten vs. SEC; Big 12 vs. Big East, etc.). At the end of the season, there would be 12 true conference champions and the top teams still standing will have truly earned their keep.
I am not against the idea of a plus-one addition to the BCS bowls. Some further tweaking of the BCS would be welcome, too. But until there is schedule reform and conference re-alignment, these distortions will continue regardless of what is done or what is implemented. But no one seems to want to talk about the importance of these issues, even though they really are the main cause of all the dissatisfaction.
It’s not the fault of the BCS, or the bowls, or the polls for all the year-end drama we see. It’s actually the pursuit of easy money by major programs that has caused the national championship process to become harder to decipher for the regular fans who love the game. Simplifying things and making sense out of the schedules and the conferences wouldn’t solve everything, but it would be a good start.
And for once, people might be satisfied that the best team actually won it all.







