Here is a quick round up of the first reactions by the media to Cam Newton’s Heisman win.
Here’s what they are saying:
So, the NCAA has ruled that Auburn quarterback Cameron Newton is eligible.
It has also ruled that his father, Cecil, did indeed request money for his son to play at Mississippi State.
From the NCAA press release on the matter:
According to facts of the case agreed upon by Auburn University and the NCAA enforcement staff, the student-athlete’s father and an owner of a scouting service worked together to actively market the student-athlete as a part of a pay-for-play scenario in return for Newton’s commitment to attend college and play football. NCAA rules (Bylaw 12.3.3) do not allow individuals or entities to represent a prospective student-athlete for compensation to a school for an athletic scholarship.
But since it has not yet been proven that Cam Newton knew of this pay-for-play scheme, he remains eligible, and it is Cecil Newton who is being punished by having his association with Auburn football curtailed (although one has to wonder how much of a punishment that is, considering the younger Newton is likely to declare for the NFL in a matter of weeks).
The effect on Heisman voters will be mixed. By the letter of the law, Newton has been deemed eligible by the NCAA and the path is therefore clear for him to accept the Heisman. But with the pay-for-play scheme now being verified by the NCAA, the spirit of the law is in a precarious position. Voters must swallow the notion that Cam Newton had no idea that he was being shopped around.
Based on the firestorm that has been created today over this matter, this can only hurt Newton’s candidacy. It certainly gives credence to the notion that his recruitment was shady and that his eligibility survives only on a technicality.
Amazingly, some commentators are saying that this ruling takes away any cloud that was hanging over Newton’s Heisman campaign and Auburn’s quest for a national title. But they’re wrong. This makes the cloud worse.
It won’t cost him the Heisman, but I think the taint is building. It could be that allowing Newton to keep his trophy inflicts more damage on the Heisman process than not allowing Reggie Bush to keep his.
The HP Heisman Watch
The Heisman Straw Poll
Total points, (with first-place votes in parentheses)
1. Marcus Mariota, QB, Oregon -- 23 (4)
2. Jameis Winston, QB, Florida State -- 18 (3)
3. Johnny Manziel, QB, Texas A&M -- 15 (3)
About The Author
Chris Huston, A.K.A. ‘The Heisman Pundit‘, is the creator and publisher of Heismanpundit.com, a site dedicated to analysis of the Heisman Trophy and college football.
"The Heisman's Foremost Authority..." -- Sports Illustrated.
"Heisman Pundit knows what he's talking about ...
which is more than I can say of some pundits."--SI's Stewart Mandel
"Heisman Pundit isn't just the authoritative site for all things Heisman...it's also an engaging, highly-opinionated place for college football discourse."--CBS's Bruce Feldman
"Heisman Pundit is the quintessential source for analysis of the greatest individual trophy in the sporting world."--The Big Ten Network's Tom Dienhart
"Indispensable."--SI's Austin Murphy
"...definitely required reading."--Those nutjobs at EDSBS
- Mariota and Petty’s big night November 7, 2013
- The Round Up November 5, 2013
- SIDs: Time for the push November 5, 2013
- The combined Ohio State quarterback November 5, 2013
- What’s Teddy Bridgewater been up to? November 5, 2013
- SEC Heisman Watch: Week 10 | NFL and NCAA FootballNFL and NCAA Football: […] Here’s a look at the national scene re...
- The Round Up | Heisman Pundit: […] with the HP Straw Poll, Marcus Mariota m...
- SEC Heisman Watch: Week 10 | Schu Football Report: […] Here’s a look at the national scene re...
- SEC Heisman Watch: Week 10 | Saturday Down South: […] Here’s a look at the national scene re...
- Curt Judy: I think you should probably re-check your math on ...